There are times when the real debate is not about art itself, but about the ability of public institutions to understand it. The case addressed by the Ombudsman of Navarre offers a revealing example.

The ruling acknowledges that a performance artwork carried out in Pamplona should have received the same treatment as a previous cultural action held in Plaza del Castillo in 1997, for which the City Council charged no fee because of its cultural purpose. A clear administrative precedent already existed.

  • The case concerned "Waking Up the City" (Despertando la ciudad), a seven-day performance art event created by performance artist NatxoZenborain in Pamplona.

But the issue goes far beyond that. The Ombudsman's report points out that the City Council attempted to impose a fee without having established the basic elements required to calculate it. There was no official measurement of the occupied space, no determination of the taxable basis, and no proper calculation of the alleged tax debt. In other words, payment was demanded without proving the minimum legal grounds necessary to justify it.

 

The Ombudsman's final recommendation was unequivocal: Ignacio Zenborain should be exempt from payment, since there was no particular benefit or quantifiable special use of public space in his favor.

 

What is most troubling is not the administrative mistake itself. Mistakes can be corrected. What is truly concerning is when bureaucracy and a lack of cultural understanding become obstacles to artistic creation. When an artist must spend more time defending the cultural value of a work than creating it, something is fundamentally wrong with the institutions involved.

 Art in public spaces does not impoverish a city. It enriches it. It generates reflection, dialogue, identity, and collective memory. What truly impoverishes a city is the inability of certain public officials to distinguish between a commercial activity and a cultural expression.

 Sometimes art needs protection from censorship. At other times, it must be protected from something far more common and insidious: administrative ignorance and the poor judgment of politicians incapable of recognizing the value of artistic creation as a shared cultural heritage.

 And when it is the Ombudsman herself who must remind public authorities of this fact, perhaps the problem was never with the artist. The problem lay with those entrusted with managing culture who failed to recognize it when it stood right before them.

Art should never have to justify its existence to ignorance. Yet history repeatedly shows that some of its greatest battles have been fought not against a lack of creativity, but against a lack of understanding. In that sense, this case is more than a personal victory. It is a reminder that cultural rights deserve the same respect, protection, and legal certainty as any other fundamental aspect of democratic life.

 

Official document from the Ombudsman of Navarre